The Possibility and Difficulties of Erlang/Elixir Hot Code Swapping in a Dockerized Environment

Temp mail SuperHeros
The Possibility and Difficulties of Erlang/Elixir Hot Code Swapping in a Dockerized Environment
The Possibility and Difficulties of Erlang/Elixir Hot Code Swapping in a Dockerized Environment

Hot Code Swapping with Erlang/Elixir and Docker: Is It Possible?

Erlang and Elixir have long been praised for their ability to perform hot code swapping, a feature that allows developers to update running applications without downtime. 🚀 Yet, this groundbreaking capability clashes with the fundamental philosophy of Docker. Docker thrives on immutable containers, where updates require stopping instances and deploying fresh images.

Imagine running a live chat application serving thousands of users. With Erlang's hot code swap, you could push a critical update without dropping a single connection. However, when Docker is introduced into the mix, things get tricky. Developers often abandon hot swapping in favor of container restarts, forfeiting one of Erlang/Elixir’s standout features.

But what if there's a way to marry these two seemingly opposing approaches? Some developers experiment with distributed systems using a hidden node to propagate updates across running containers. This approach sounds risky but intriguing. Could this method maintain stability while enabling seamless updates? đŸ€”

In this article, we’ll explore whether it’s possible to achieve hot code swapping in a Dockerized Erlang/Elixir environment. We’ll share practical insights, do’s and don’ts, and uncover potential caveats for those daring enough to bridge the gap between Docker and dynamic code updates.

Command Example of use
net_kernel:start/1 Initializes a hidden or visible node in an Erlang distributed system. It allows nodes to communicate securely within the cluster.
rpc:call/4 Executes a remote procedure call on a specified node, allowing functions like code updates to be triggered on distributed nodes.
code:add_patha/1 Adds a path to the Erlang runtime's code search paths dynamically, enabling new code to be loaded without restarting the node.
code:load_file/1 Loads a specific module file into the running Erlang/Elixir node, allowing the updated version of the module to take effect.
Node.list/0 Returns a list of nodes currently connected to the running node, crucial for broadcasting updates across a distributed system.
Node.spawn/2 Spawns a process on a remote node to execute a function, useful for initiating tasks like code updates on other nodes.
Code.append_path/1 Adds a directory path to Elixir's code loader, dynamically extending the runtime code lookup for new or updated modules.
docker build -t Builds a Docker image from a specified Dockerfile and tags it for deployment. It is essential for preparing updated code images.
docker run -d Starts a new container in detached mode using a specified image, ensuring that the container runs in the background with minimal downtime.
docker stop Stops a running Docker container, allowing the application to be updated before starting a new instance with the updated image.

Achieving Hot Code Swapping for Erlang/Elixir in Docker

One of the standout features of the Erlang/Elixir ecosystem is its ability to perform hot code swapping. This means developers can push new code updates to a running system without interrupting services or losing connections. However, when combined with Docker, which emphasizes immutable containers and restarting for updates, this feature seems at odds. The scripts above address this by leveraging a hidden node to distribute updates across connected nodes dynamically, bridging Erlang/Elixir’s capabilities with Docker’s infrastructure. 🚀

In the first script, the Erlang command net_kernel:start/1 initializes a hidden node that serves as a central dispatcher for updates. Hidden nodes do not register themselves publicly in the cluster, making them ideal for management tasks like code updates. The command rpc:call/4 allows the hidden node to execute remote code calls on other nodes, such as dynamically loading a new version of a module. A real-world example could involve updating a live chat server while thousands of users are connected without restarting the entire service.

The second script demonstrates similar functionality using Elixir. The Code.append_path/1 command dynamically extends the runtime’s code lookup path, enabling the system to locate new module versions. This, combined with Node.list/0, allows the script to push updates across all connected nodes seamlessly. Imagine running an e-commerce system that needs an urgent fix for its payment service. By distributing the update using a hidden node, you can apply the patch instantly without disrupting ongoing transactions. đŸ€”

The third script focuses on Docker and introduces a fallback solution for developers who prefer container restarts over complex distributed updates. It automates the process of building a new Docker image, stopping the current container, and restarting a new one in detached mode. The commands docker build and docker run -d ensure minimal downtime. While this approach doesn’t enable live code updates like the Erlang/Elixir-specific methods, it offers a practical and reliable option for teams heavily invested in Docker infrastructure.

Hot Code Swapping with Erlang/Elixir in Docker Containers: Modular Solutions

Backend solution using Erlang/Elixir with a hidden node for distributed updates

% Define the Erlang distributed system setup
-module(hot_code_swap).
-export([start_hidden_node/0, distribute_update/1]).

% Start a hidden node for code updates
start_hidden_node() ->
    NodeName = "hidden_node@127.0.0.1",
    Cookie = mycookie,
    {ok, _} = net_kernel:start([{hidden, NodeName}, Cookie]),
    io:format("Hidden node started successfully~n").

% Distribute new code to other nodes
distribute_update(CodePath) ->
    Nodes = nodes(),
    io:format("Distributing code update to nodes: ~p~n", [Nodes]),
    lists:foreach(fun(Node) ->
        rpc:call(Node, code, add_patha, [CodePath]),
        rpc:call(Node, code, load_file, [my_module])
    end, Nodes).

% Example usage
% hot_code_swap:start_hidden_node().
% hot_code_swap:distribute_update("/path/to/new/code").

Updating Elixir Code with a Hot-Swappable Docker-Based Setup

Backend solution using Elixir with code reloading and node management

defmodule HotCodeSwap do
  @moduledoc "Handles hot code swapping in a distributed environment."

  # Start a hidden node for managing updates
  def start_hidden_node do
    :net_kernel.start([:"hidden_node@127.0.0.1", :hidden])
    IO.puts("Hidden node started.")
  end

  # Function to push updates to other nodes
  def distribute_update(code_path) do
    nodes = Node.list()
    IO.puts("Updating nodes: #{inspect(nodes)}")

    Enum.each(nodes, fn node ->
      :rpc.call(node, Code, :append_path, [code_path])
      :rpc.call(node, Code, :load_file, ["my_module.ex"])
    end)
  end
end

# Example usage
HotCodeSwap.start_hidden_node()
HotCodeSwap.distribute_update("/path/to/new/code")

Automating Docker Build and Restart for Hot Code Updates

Script for managing Docker containers with minimal downtime

#!/bin/bash
# Script to automate Docker-based hot code swapping

APP_NAME="my_elixir_app"
NEW_TAG="my_app:latest"
CONTAINER_NAME="elixir_app_container"

echo "Building new Docker image..."
docker build -t $NEW_TAG .

echo "Checking running container..."
RUNNING_CONTAINER=$(docker ps -q -f name=$CONTAINER_NAME)

if [ -n "$RUNNING_CONTAINER" ]; then
    echo "Stopping current container..."
    docker stop $CONTAINER_NAME
fi

echo "Starting updated container..."
docker run -d --name $CONTAINER_NAME $NEW_TAG
echo "Hot swap completed!"

Unit Tests for Distributed Erlang Hot Code Swap

Unit test suite written in Erlang to verify code distribution

-module(hot_code_swap_tests).
-include_lib("eunit/include/eunit.hrl").

start_hidden_node_test() ->
    ?assertMatch({ok, _}, net_kernel:start([{hidden, "test_node@127.0.0.1"}, test_cookie])).

distribute_update_test() ->
    CodePath = "/tmp/new_code",
    Nodes = [node1@127.0.0.1, node2@127.0.0.1],
    lists:foreach(fun(Node) ->
        ?assertEqual(ok, rpc:call(Node, code, add_patha, [CodePath]))
    end, Nodes).

Balancing Docker Immutability with Erlang/Elixir Hot Code Swapping

Hot code swapping in Erlang and Elixir allows systems to update code without downtime, a feature highly valued in distributed and fault-tolerant applications. However, Docker containers emphasize immutability, where an updated container is deployed by stopping the old instance. This mismatch creates challenges for developers who want the flexibility of Erlang/Elixir with the predictability of Docker-based systems. Exploring solutions that bridge these approaches is essential.

One possible workaround involves separating the update layer from the application layer. By using a hidden node or a control process, you can push updates to connected nodes without rebuilding the entire container. The hidden node serves as a manager, distributing updates to dynamically load updated modules using commands like rpc:call or code:load_file. This avoids Docker’s restart process while retaining system uptime. A practical example would be a live video streaming service that can’t afford interruptions; dynamic updates ensure smooth transitions for viewers. 🚀

For projects requiring a balance of both worlds, hybrid solutions exist. Developers can use a secondary node to test updates, then apply them across the network while running minimal restarts for critical changes. Combining techniques like hot code loading and Docker image versioning provides both flexibility and safety. For example, a health monitoring system might load critical patches immediately while non-urgent updates are applied during planned deployments.

Erlang/Elixir Hot Code Swap and Docker: FAQs

  1. What is hot code swapping in Erlang/Elixir?
  2. Hot code swapping allows developers to update a running application without stopping it, using commands like code:load_file.
  3. Why does Docker conflict with hot code swapping?
  4. Docker focuses on immutability, requiring updates to be deployed with a fresh container using commands like docker build and docker run.
  5. What is the role of a hidden node in hot code swapping?
  6. A hidden node, started with net_kernel:start, can distribute updates to other nodes without becoming publicly visible in the cluster.
  7. Can hot code swapping work alongside Docker containers?
  8. Yes, by using a control node to push updates dynamically or separating application updates from container management processes.
  9. What are the limitations of hot code swapping?
  10. While powerful, it requires careful planning to avoid version conflicts, and complex updates may still necessitate a full container restart.
  11. How does Docker ensure reliability in updates?
  12. Docker uses commands like docker stop and docker run -d to restart applications cleanly with minimal downtime.
  13. What are the benefits of combining Docker and hot code swapping?
  14. This combination ensures near-zero downtime for updates, ideal for critical systems like payment gateways or real-time communication apps.
  15. How can you validate distributed code updates?
  16. Use commands like rpc:call to verify updates across nodes and implement automated unit tests for safety.
  17. What kind of projects benefit the most from hot code swapping?
  18. Applications requiring high availability, like live streaming platforms, IoT systems, or multiplayer games, benefit significantly.
  19. Can hybrid approaches work for managing updates?
  20. Yes, by using Docker for base deployments and hot swapping for live updates, you can achieve both safety and flexibility.

Key Takeaways for Balancing Docker and Hot Code Swapping

Bringing hot code swapping to a Dockerized environment requires blending modern container practices with Erlang/Elixir’s dynamic code features. While it sounds complex, it’s achievable with careful planning and distributed update strategies.

Using hidden nodes to broadcast changes allows teams to maintain uptime for critical systems. For simpler workflows, combining container restarts with strategic hot swaps offers a reliable solution, minimizing disruptions. 🔧

Sources and References for Hot Code Swapping in Docker
  1. Explains the implementation of hot code swapping in Erlang systems: Erlang Code Replacement Documentation .
  2. Discusses Docker’s immutable infrastructure and containerization practices: Docker Official Documentation .
  3. Combining Erlang/Elixir with distributed systems and live code upgrades: Elixir Distributed Tasks Guide .
  4. Real-world insights into distributed Erlang hidden nodes for updates: It’s About the Guarantees .